True story: back in 1999, at the height of the dotcom boom, my husband and I had an idea for a review site that would be accessible via both the web and mobile phones. It would be a site where anyone could review and rank any kind of product or service.
This was just one of many ideas we had - being typical entrepreneurs we were full of them - and it was a heady time when anything seemed possible. The only problem was that we were already flat-out building our first Internet startup (an Internet security company) and had no time to pursue anything else.
Fast-forward to today and review sites seem to be everywhere, as highlighted by a recent article in The New York Times. While the author, Randall Stross, worries about anonymous, unqualified or biased reviewers on many of these sites (like book authors using pseudonyms to post favorable reviews about their own books), he seems enamored by one of the most popular review sites: Yelp.
According to Mr Stross, Yelp reviewers take a more professional approach to their work. Indeed, Yelp reviewers who consistently produce quality, amusing, well-considered reviews are rewarded for doing so by being appointed to the ‘Yelp Elite Squad’. Stross also like the fact that reviewers are also subject to Yelp member scrutiny.
There are plenty of other review sites. Actually, there are plenty of product review sites that don’t really offer genuine reviews but, rather, exist primarily to sell affiliate products or generate Google Adsense clicks. Such sites primarily aim to drive visitors to click on an ad or affiliate link rather than fully educate them about a given product or service.
That’s NOT to say there are no sites with an affiliate or Adsense based business model that offer objective, thoughtful, helpful product reviews. Some do. They just appear to be in the minority.
Meanwhile, the popularity of Yelp – which, according to comScore data, attracted 4.76 million unique visitors in July 2008 - indicates that despite the appeal of ‘peer’ reviews, and despite the proliferation of all kinds of review sites, people are eager for objective advice from authoritative, trustworthy sources.
‘Authoritative’ and ‘trustworthy’ doesn’t necessarily mean ‘professional reviewer’ but it may mean someone who appears to be credible and objective.
Like most things, winners and losers will emerge from among all these review sites. It’s sites that can make money whilst providing genuine value to their visitors or customers that are likely to be the winners.
Source: Randall Stross, “How Many Reviewers Should Be in the Kitchen?”, The New York Times, September 7, 2008